Thousands of Keurig cups were recently recalled for being mislabeled as decaffeinated, when they contained caffeine. This posed a health risk to those living with high blood pressure, arrhythmias, and gastric reflux. Apart from this dangerous mix-up, there are plenty of reasons why you should ditch your Keurig for an alternative brewing method in 2026.
By Jayne Turner – Staff Writer
Taste and Quality of Coffee
Keurigs often brew weaker and less flavorful coffee when compared with other methods. Since K-cups contain pre-ground coffee, they can go stale, reducing quality. Though convenient, you are suffering through mediocre coffee.
Environmental Impact
K-cups generate a lot of unnecessary waste. The amount of K-cups that have been trashed in landfills could wrap around the planet 10 times. Yeah. Even the recyclable pods require special processing that often gets ignored in trash collection.
They do sell reusable K-Cup coffee filters, but that means you’ll still be buying your own beans or grounds, so while it is an environmental benefit, it is less convenient. Beware! Some users report that the reusable K-Cup does not work well, producing an undrinkable cup of coffee or causing the Keurig to malfunction.
Long-term cost
K-cups cost more per cup than buying coffee beans, so you’ll save money if you brew with reusable filters and whole bean coffee. If you do the math, K-Cups cost between $0.40 and $0.60 per cup, which is up to $50 per pound of coffee. Regular coffee grounds are often only $0.14 to $0.20 per cup, depending on how fancy your beans are. K-Cups are 3-5x more expensive than regular coffee per cup!
You may also like: 5 Neuroscience Books for Beginners
Maintenance
Keurigs, like many automatic coffee machines, need regular descaling and cleaning. Mineral buildup occurs rapidly and affects the machine’s performance as well as the taste of the coffee. Simple coffee makers or pour-overs are much quicker to clean.
If you drink coffee every day but aren’t willing to commit to maintenance, you are better off using a different brewing method.
Ritual
If you have had your Keurig for years, but have an interest in coffee culture, get rid of your Keurig! Mastering a new brewing method is an enjoyable activity that turns into a mindful ritual. As you grow to appreciate the craft of coffee, a Keurig won’t cut it anymore.
Check out this segment of Books that Changed My Life.
What are the Alternatives?
Drip coffee maker: For daily coffee drinkers who don’t care too much about the fancy flavors that are offered in K-Cups, a regular drip coffee maker is a great option. Some even come with a timer, so you can set your coffee maker to start brewing for you, no pod required. Just set it up and leave it overnight. Who doesn’t love waking up to the smell of coffee?
Pour over: This single-cup brewing method provides control over the strength, temperature, and flavor of your coffee. Though this isn’t the method for those on the go, it is a nice habit to get into on the weekends. Chemex and V60 are popular brands for pour-over setups, but it doesn’t have to be expensive.
Pro-tip: Add a little cinnamon to the filter with the grounds. Trust me.
Espresso machine: For those who are looking to jump into the deep end of at-home coffee making, an espresso machine is the way to go. Be prepared to work at it and tinker with methods; there is a serious learning curve to pulling espresso and steaming milk.
